CAA Benchmark Problem Category 4

Case	Radial Phase Shift	Tip Mach Number	Results
1	0	0.470	[Table]
4	0	0.783	[Table]
8	2	0.783	[Table]

---

Case 1: q=0, M_T=0.470

Upstream

m	μ	Namba	Schulten	RPMTurbo 240x16x16	RPMTurbo 240x25x16	RPMTurbo 480x25x16	RPMTurbo 120x25x16
16	0	6.846e-05	5.581e-05	6.258E-05	6.254E-05	6.214E-05	6.133E-05
16	1	9.215e-06	9.141e-06	8.404E-06	8.497E-06	8.455E-06	7.964E-06
16	2	2.437e-06	2.328e-06	2.455E-06	3.411E-06	3.382E-06	3.617E-06
16	3	6.576e-07	6.603e-07	6.007E-07	5.819E-07	5.699E-07	1.033E-06
16	4	9.022e-08	9.475e-08	9.861E-08	1.050E-07	7.611E-08	5.171E-07
-8	0	2.849e-03	3.228e-03	3.418E-03	3.433E-03	3.419E-03	3.455E-03
-8	1	4.699e-04	3.635e-04	3.969E-04	3.980E-04	3.941E-04	4.054E-04
-8	2	6.684e-05	5.424e-05	5.609E-05	5.676E-05	5.599E-05	5.825E-05
-8	3	2.697e-06	2.961e-06	3.130E-06	3.227E-06	3.167E-06	3.294E-06
-8	4	1.235e-07	1.403e-07	8.047E-07	1.444E-06	1.441E-06	1.660E-06

Downstream

m	μ	Namba	Schulten	RPMTurbo 240x16x16	RPMTurbo 240x25x16	RPMTurbo 480x25x16	RPMTurbo 120x25x16
16	0	7.903e-05	7.785e-05	8.360E-05	8.433E-05	8.321E-05	8.651E-05
16	1	4.415e-06	4.631e-06	5.356E-06	5.385E-06	5.228E-06	6.104E-06
16	2	6.765e-07	6.260e-07	9.523E-07	1.193E-06	1.057E-06	2.296E-06
16	3	1.562e-07	1.190e-07	2.243E-07	2.316E-07	1.709E-07	8.062E-07
16	4	1.881e-08	1.154e-08	1.070E-07	6.495E-08	7.501E-08	4.991E-07
-8	0	1.064e-02	1.096e-02	9.467E-03	9.501E-03	9.464E-03	9.566E-03
-8	1	2.600e-04	2.025e-04	2.540E-04	2.535E-04	2.518E-04	2.562E-04
-8	2	2.671e-05	1.290e-05	2.443E-05	2.446E-05	2.426E-05	2.471E-05
-8	3	8.510e-07	4.741e-07	1.497E-06	1.474E-06	1.426E-06	1.529E-06
-8	4	3.212e-08	1.778e-08	2.529E-07	4.512E-07	3.991E-07	9.597E-07

---

Case 4: q=0, M_T=0.783

Upstream

m	μ	Namba	Schulten	RPMTurbo 240x16x16	RPMTurbo 240x25x16	RPMTurbo 480x25x16	RPMTurbo 120x25x16
16	0	7.395E-04	7.064E-04	6.213E-04	6.260E-04	6.205E-04	6.348E-04
16	1	2.417E-05	2.487E-05	2.273E-05	2.283E-05	2.251E-05	2.447E-05
16	2	3.326E-06	3.329E-06	3.569E-06	4.570E-06	4.473E-06	8.759E-06
16	3	7.577E-07	7.299E-07	8.583E-07	9.020E-07	8.157E-07	4.007E-06
16	4	8.646E-08	8.635E-08	1.767E-07	2.596E-07	1.121E-07	2.086E-06
-8	0	1.178E-02	1.174E-02	1.113E-02	1.116E-02	1.117E-02	1.109E-02
-8	1	1.930E-02	1.906E-02	1.526E-02	1.535E-02	1.531E-02	1.533E-02
-8	2	2.201E-04	1.346E-04	2.456E-04	2.517E-04	2.493E-04	2.554E-04
-8	3	5.283E-06	4.248E-06	8.222E-06	8.460E-06	8.418E-06	8.572E-06
-8	4	1.236E-07	1.294E-07	7.283E-07	1.703E-06	1.676E-06	3.659E-06

Downstream

m	μ	Namba	Schulten	RPMTurbo 240x16x16	RPMTurbo 240x25x16	RPMTurbo 480x25x16	RPMTurbo 120x25x16
16	0	1.045E-04	1.053E-04	1.207E-04	1.232E-04	1.252E-04	1.158E-04
16	1	1.172E-05	1.025E-05	1.183E-05	1.198E-05	1.213E-05	9.784E-06
16	2	2.237E-06	2.375E-06	2.182E-06	2.751E-06	2.938E-06	4.087E-06
16	3	4.373E-07	5.301E-07	3.600E-07	3.686E-07	4.010E-07	2.324E-06
16	4	4.869E-08	6.161E-08	1.473E-07	1.634E-07	1.352E-07	1.536E-06
-8	0	1.714E-02	1.497E-02	1.263E-02	1.265E-02	1.263E-02	1.267E-02
-8	1	1.895E-02	1.785E-02	1.595E-02	1.612E-02	1.612E-02	1.609E-02
-8	2	1.863E-04	2.670E-04	1.495E-04	1.444E-04	1.420E-04	1.475E-04
-8	3	2.804E-06	4.294E-06	3.922E-06	3.837E-06	3.851E-06	3.868E-06
-8	4	9.504E-08	1.232E-07	3.457E-07	9.113E-07	1.120E-06	1.666E-06

---

Case 8: q=2.0, M_T=0.783

Upstream m μ Namba Schulten RPMTurbo 240x16x16 16 0 1.754E-04 1.660E-04 1.274E-04 16 1 7.186E-06 7.070E-06 1.008E-05 16 2 2.295E-06 2.182E-06 1.742E-06 16 3 1.245E-06 1.236E-06 1.112E-06 16 4 4.322E-07 3.949E-07 1.318E-06 -8 0 8.901E-04 9.453E-04 4.260E-04 -8 1 4.830E-03 3.837E-03 3.202E-03 -8 2 1.195E-04 2.264E-04 2.661E-04 -8 3 3.000E-05 2.817E-05 2.334E-05 -8 4 2.750E-06 2.545E-06 3.436E-06

Downstream m μ Namba Schulten RPMTurbo 240x16x16 16 0 2.062E-05 1.052E-05 3.849E-05 16 1 3.734E-06 4.984E-06 7.059E-06 16 2 6.548E-07 5.383E-07 7.145E-07 16 3 1.372E-07 9.921E-08 4.773E-07 16 4 1.551E-08 1.115E-08 8.060E-07 -8 0 3.363E-03 3.099E-03 2.725E-03 -8 1 6.073E-03 6.698E-03 6.400E-03 -8 2 1.368E-04 1.490E-04 2.101E-04 -8 3 6.695E-07 1.730E-06 2.911E-07 -8 4 3.708E-08 1.625E-08 2.582E-07

---

---